Thursday, August 09, 2007

A Surprise from Jurgen

I'm coming to the end of Philip Jenkins' God's Continent, and was very surprised by this passage quoted from Habermas' recent Time of Transitions (April 2006):

Christianity, and nothing else, is the ultimate foundation of liberty, conscience, human rights, and democracy, the benchmarks of Western civilization. To this day, we have no other options [to Christianity]. Everything else is postmodern chatter.


Jenkins quotes further from the book Habermas' declaration that he is "enchanted by the seriousness and consistency" of Aquinas,

a spiritual figure who was able to prove his authenticity with his own resources. That contemporary religious leadership lacks an equally solid terrain seems to me an incontrovertible truth. In the general leveling of society by the media everything seems to lose seriousness, even institutionalized Christianity. But theology would lose its identity if it sought to uncouple itself from the dogmatic nucleus of religion, and thus from the religious language in which the community's practices of prayer, confession, and faith are made concrete.

4 comments:

Define Me said...

Is it a surprise to you given Habermas' avowed atheism? I ask because you know a lot more about Habermas than I do.

Nimble Jack said...

Yes, exactly. I've never heard Habermas being anti-religious in any rhetorical, and certainly not in any philosophical, sense, but I always got the feeling that was more because he's justlo a really nice, humble guy who honestly believes his own ideas about respecting one's interlocutors and learning from their ideas.

This is very different in tone from anything I ever read (of course I haven't read everything). It's much more forcefully, substantively positive in regards to theism and Christianity in particular.

Chris said...

That is weird. I wonder what he means by Christianity. And what he means by everything else being postmodern chatter. He’s not a Christian right? Would that make his theory of communicative action postmodern chatter?

“To this day, we have no other options” for what?

Nimble Jack said...

Here's some more:

http://www.cathnews.com/news/411/131.php